Lawyers still get work by referral, but the referral no longer ends with the referral: the person looks the name up on Google before calling. What they find there decides whether they call. And among twenty firms offering exactly the same list of services, what sets one apart is not the design.
Lawyers still get work by referral. That has not changed and probably will not: nobody hands a delicate matter to a stranger because they came up first in a search. What has changed is what happens between the referral and the phone call. Someone gives you a name, and that person — before dialling — types it into Google. What they find there decides whether they dial.
The referral no longer ends with the referral
Run the exercise from the other side. You are given a lawyer's name, you look it up, and you find three things: a LinkedIn profile last updated in 2019, a directory listing with a phone number that no longer works, and nothing else. Then you look up the second name you were given and find a proper site, with the professional's face, the areas they take on and a text explaining how they work. You do not need to be an expert to know which of the two gets called first.
A website does not replace the referral: it confirms it. That is its entire job in this profession, and it is an expensive job to leave undone, because referrals lost this way never announce themselves. Nobody calls to tell you they did not call.
The client cannot judge your legal judgement
Someone looking for a lawyer is in no position to assess the quality of a brief or the strategy behind a case. If they were, they would not need a lawyer. What they assess are indirect signals, and it is worth being clear about them, because those are what you have to put in plain sight:
- A name and a face. The anonymous firm with not a single photograph starts at a disadvantage against the one that shows who will handle the case.
- Verifiable details: bar association membership number, physical address, a phone number somebody answers.
- Specific practice areas instead of a list covering all of law.
- Some explanation of the process: what happens at the first meeting, what documents to bring, how fees work.
- Provable track record: years in practice, the kind of matters handled, teaching or publications if there are any.
None of that is design. It is information you already have and that today is written down nowhere someone can read it at nine at night, which is when people look for a lawyer.
The underlying problem: everybody offers the same thing
Open five Costa Rican law firm sites and you will read almost the same page: civil, criminal, employment, family, commercial, traffic, immigration, notarial. Next to a photo of a shelf of law books or a gavel, an object our courts do not even use. If your site says what the other nineteen say, the client has nothing to choose on and ends up choosing on price or proximity.
Standing out does not come from a better-written line on the home page. It comes from accepting that not everything you do brings in clients equally, and giving the site over to the part that does. A lawyer who takes on all sorts of matters can still have what is plainly the best page in the country on child maintenance, or on wrongful dismissal, or on residency by family ties. That page is the one that brings people in.
How standing out on Google actually works
When somebody searches for "employment lawyer in San José" they do not get one list: they get two different results competing for the same space. At the top, a map with three business listings. Below it, the usual links. These are two competitions with separate rules, and they have to be played separately.
The map is decided above all by the Google Business Profile: the listing with the address, opening hours, phone number and reviews. Proximity between the searcher and the office counts for a great deal, which is an enormous advantage for a firm in a small canton and a real limitation for one hoping to appear across the whole metropolitan area. A firm without a verified listing does not appear on that map even with the best website in the country.
The links below are decided by content: what pages you have, what questions they answer and who links to or mentions you. Proximity barely counts there, which is why it is the ground where a small practice can beat a large one — if it writes about something specific while the large one sticks to its list of twenty practice areas.
One page per practice area, not a list of practice areas
The concrete change is this: take each practice area out of the list and give it its own page, written out in full. Not three lines; a page that answers what the person is actually asking themselves at that hour. How long does this take. What might it cost and what does that depend on. What documents do I need. What happens if the other side does not respond. Can I do it without a lawyer, and what am I risking if I do.
Those answers are what people type into the search box, word for word, and they are also what no directory can have, because they require knowing the law. It is the only content a firm can produce that its marketing competitors cannot. Written in plain language, too: if the text reads like a court filing, the client closes it.
One side effect worth having: those same pages are what AI assistants cite today when somebody asks them about a legal procedure. A text that explains itself can be quoted on its own; a list of practice areas cannot.
Reviews matter, and in this profession they are awkward
Reviews are one of the strongest factors in the map result, and the profession starts at a disadvantage: nobody wants to leave a public record of having gone through a divorce or a criminal case. That is a legitimate reason and not one to argue with.
What you can do is ask where the matter exposes nobody: incorporations, property transfers, powers of attorney, notarised documents, corporate advice, registry filings. That is enough to keep the listing alive. And answer all of them, the bad ones included, carefully: replying to a complaint by going into the details of the case is a confidentiality problem, not a defence. A "we are sorry about your experience, please write to us so we can discuss it privately" closes the matter without opening another.
What professional ethics allow and what they do not
Advertising by legal professionals in Costa Rica is governed by the bar association's code of professional conduct, and it is worth reading before publishing rather than after. The practical rule is simple: the information has to be truthful, verifiable and not misleading.
In website terms that rules out the obvious: promising outcomes, guaranteeing you win the case, inventing success rates, claiming specialisations that are not accredited, or publishing client details without authorisation. It does not rule out — and this is what a lot of people over-assume — describing your areas, setting out your experience, explaining how you charge, or writing articles on your field. For a specific doubt, asking the bar association costs nothing and is cheaper than taking the site down later.
The enquiry arrives outside office hours
The peak in searches for a lawyer is not at ten in the morning: it is at night and at weekends, when the person is alone with the problem. If all there is at that hour is an office phone number, the enquiry goes to the next result.
The minimum to leave in place: a short form — name, phone and two lines about the matter, nothing more — WhatsApp with a preloaded message, and a clear note that sending the form creates no lawyer-client relationship and does not constitute legal advice. That line protects both sides and heads off a conflict of interest if the opposing party writes in first. And use email on your own domain: taking confidential matters through a free address shared around the office is an uncomfortable conversation waiting to happen.
Where to start if there is nothing today
In order, because doing it the other way round is the commonest way to waste the budget:
- The Google Business Profile, verified and complete. It is free, it takes an afternoon and it is the only thing that puts you on the map.
- A five-page site: home, who you are, one page for each of your two or three main practice areas, and contact. Short and finished beats large and half-done.
- The articles answering the questions in those areas, one a month. This is the part that compounds, and the part almost nobody keeps up.
- Reviews, asked for consistently from the clients who are able to leave them.
And an honest expectation on timing: the listing can start moving the phone within weeks, but ranking the practice-area pages takes months. Anyone promising you first position in thirty days is describing something they do not control.
If you like, we can look at your particular case: which area is worth working on first, what comes up today when somebody searches your name, and what is missing for that search to end in a phone call. The first conversation costs nothing.
Want us to review your site or build a new one?
